Cat Krumbles
Senior Member
Chinese
- Apr 10, 2021
- #1
Hi,
Context: I was asked when easter would easter for me and I said "the week starting on the 19th" to express the idea that it will start on the 19th.
Have I used it right and does it mean the same as 'the week that starts on the 19th'
B
bwac14
Senior Member
Michigan
English - US
- Apr 10, 2021
- #2
We say: the week of the 19th = the week that
the 19th of the month
Edit: I meant to say that the week of the 19th = the week that includes the 19th of the month
Last edited:
Cat Krumbles
Senior Member
Chinese
- Apr 10, 2021
- #3
bwac14 said:
We say: the week of the 19th = the week that starts on the 19th of the month
How about 'the week beginning on the 19th'?
B
bwac14
Senior Member
Michigan
English - US
- Apr 10, 2021
- #4
I changed my previous post because I made a mistake.
You could say: "the week beginning on the 19th" and "the week that starts on the 19th" but they're not very idiomatic.
Whether the 19th is the first day of the week or not, using "the week of the 19th" will refer to the same week and it's what I would use.
Uncle Jack
Senior Member
Cumbria, UK
British English
- Apr 10, 2021
- #5
I would say "the week beginning the nineteenth", but "the week starting the nineteenth" would be fine. Except that I don't see how this fits with Easter. We usually refer to Easter as being just one day, a Sunday, when the Resurrection is celebrated, so mentioning the previous Monday makes very little sense. Alternatively, it might be the period from Friday to Sunday (or Friday to Monday in Britain, since the Monday after Easter is a public holiday), which make referring to the preceding Monday equally nonsensical. Finally, there is Easter Week, but in the Western Church this begins on Palm Sunday, the Sunday before Easter Day, so once again it makes no sense to refer to a Monday.
Cat Krumbles
Senior Member
Chinese
- Apr 10, 2021
- #6
bwac14 said:
I changed my previous post because I made a mistake.
You could say: "the week beginning on the 19th" and "the week that starts on the 19th" but they're not very idiomatic.
Whether the 19th is the first day of the week or not, using "the week of the 19th" will refer to the same week and it's what I would use.
Thank you!
Cat Krumbles
Senior Member
Chinese
- Apr 10, 2021
- #7
Uncle Jack said:
I would say "the week beginning the nineteenth", but "the week starting the nineteenth" would be fine. Except that I don't see how this fits with Easter. We usually refer to Easter as being just one day, a Sunday, when the Resurrection is celebrated, so mentioning the previous Monday makes very little sense. Alternatively, it might be the period from Friday to Sunday (or Friday to Monday in Britain, since the Monday after Easter is a public holiday), which make referring to the preceding Monday equally nonsensical. Finally, there is Easter Week, but in the Western Church this begins on Palm Sunday, the Sunday before Easter Day, so once again it makes no sense to refer to a Monday.
Hi, so there is no need for the preposition 'on' then? (the week beginning on the nineteenth)?
R
Rover_KE
Senior Member
Northwest England - near Blackburn, Lancashire
British English
- Apr 10, 2021
- #8
No.
elroy
Moderator: EHL, Arabic, Hebrew, German(-Spanish)
Chicago, IL
US English, Palestinian Arabic bilingual
- Apr 11, 2021
- #9
bwac14 said:
Whether the 19th is the first day of the week or not, using "the week of the 19th" will refer to the same week and it's what I would use.
I would only use it if the 19th were the Monday of that week.
If the 19th is the Wednesday, I would say “the week of the 17th.”
Cat Krumbles
Senior Member
Chinese
- Apr 11, 2021
- #10
elroy said:
I would only use it if the 19th were the Monday of that week.
If the 19th is the Wednesday, I would say “the week of the 17th.”
Thank you, elroy
You must log in or register to reply here.